This theme depicts the Treaty as a historical document that is irrelevant to the present and which blocks development. It links strongly with themes 4: ‘Māori privilege’; 5: ‘Good Māori/Bad Māori’; and 11: ‘Māori resources’.
Treaty/grievance industry, grievance mode, gravy train, divisive, never-ending, Treatyism, the past is the past, undermine democracy; and any calls to dispense with the Treaty.
• ‘Treaty of Waitangi claims are continuing to delay the sale of Masterton’s abandoned schools’ (Dominion Post, 19 Feb, 2008).
• ‘…when the orchestrated grievance display that is Waitangi Day passes…’ (Manawatu Standard editorial, 7 Feb, 2007)
• Pākehā are entitled to determine the worth and meaning of the Treaty on their own.
• Any decision or process that treats the views of Māori and non-Māori equally is undemocratic.
• A treaty signed more than 170 years ago is no longer relevant.
• Undermines any consideration of the Treaty in debates or conflicts between Māori and Pākehā
• Ensures that Pākehā institutions such as the police, courts and Parliament settle issues, which will usually benefit Pākehā at the expense of Māori.
• Explain the Crown’s breaches of te Tiriti at issue.
• Te Tiriti is a contract enabling Pākehā to live justly in Aotearoa, by according Māori rights as tangata whenua
• Te Tiriti was an agreement between two sovereign peoples, with Māori having an equal say in any interpretation
• Te Tiriti should be a foundation for a new constitution enabling a just, Treaty-based future.
• The Magna Carta was signed in 1215 but current laws banning arbitrary arrest and justice for sale are still based on it.
• The inadequacies of media reporting about the Treaty undermine the ability of Pākehā and other non-Māori to consider their Tiriti obligations.
• Pākehā anxiety about their place in Aotearoa will be resolved only through honouring the Tiriti and acknowledging Māori as tangata whenua.
• For the government to determine on its own how claims about Treaty breaches will be settled is unjust - the process should be agreed by both parties.